Here’s a bold statement: one actor’s plea to bring back a controversial reality star just left a TV executive speechless—and it’s sparking a debate that’s as fiery as the show itself. But here’s where it gets controversial... During a recent episode of Watch What Happens Live, actor Lukas Gage dropped a bombshell opinion that left host Andy Cohen and fellow guest Whitney Rose momentarily stunned. Gage didn’t hold back, openly begging Cohen to reconsider bringing Jen Shah back to The Real Housewives of Salt Lake City once she completes her prison sentence next year. Yes, that Jen Shah—the one convicted for her role in a telemarketing scheme targeting vulnerable individuals. And this is the part most people miss... Gage’s argument wasn’t about condoning her actions but about the undeniable entertainment value she brings to the show. ‘She’s great for the show,’ he insisted, adding, ‘If it’s OK for the federal government to give her a second chance, why not Bravo?’
Cohen, however, wasn’t swayed. While he admitted the idea of Shah reuniting with Elizabeth Holmes (her fellow inmate and disgraced Theranos founder) could make for wild TV, he reminded everyone that the show has thrived without her for four seasons. Still, Gage’s plea raises a thought-provoking question: Should reality TV prioritize redemption arcs, or is some behavior simply unforgivable on screen? Boldly, we ask: Is there room for second chances in the spotlight, or does accountability demand permanent removal?
For context, Shah’s six-and-a-half-year sentence began in early 2023, with her release now set for October 2026. Cohen has been vocal about his stance, once declaring, ‘Jen Shah… I never want to see again.’ Yet, Shah’s team claims there are ‘no hard feelings’ after behind-the-scenes talks with Bravo. Whether you love her or loathe her, one thing’s clear: Jen Shah’s legacy on RHOSLC is far from over. What do you think? Should Jen Shah get another shot, or has she overstayed her welcome? Let’s debate in the comments!
Watch What Happens Live airs Sunday through Thursday at 10 p.m. ET on Bravo, with new episodes streaming the next day on Peacock.
